By Mike Dunkling, founder of Zatheo, a web design and SEO agency in Ashford, Kent.
Here’s a conversation I have a lot. A business is running ads, enquiries are coming in, and hardly anyone is turning into a customer. So the first suggestion is to change the ads. New images, new wording, a bigger budget, a different audience.
Sometimes that’s the right call. More often, when I look properly, the clicks are fine. People are turning up. The problem is what happens to them once they arrive.
If we see loads of people come to a landing page but no one’s signing up, it normally means there’s a problem with the landing page. Or the form. Or the first message they get back. Spending more on ads just sends more people into the same leak.
Follow one enquiry all the way through
The easiest way to find the leak is to be the customer. Click your own ad, land on your own page, fill in your own form, and then watch what happens over the next two weeks.
It sounds obvious, but very few businesses do it. The ads get looked at constantly because that’s where the money goes. The page gets looked at when it’s built. The follow-up gets set up once and then nobody reads it again.
When you go through it as a customer, ask yourself a few plain questions at each step:
- Is it clear what I’m getting and what I should do next?
- Has anything actually happened yet, or am I waiting for someone to get back to me?
- If I went quiet now, what would bring me back?
You’ll usually find the answer to at least one of those is uncomfortable.
Don’t leave people waiting
This is the one I see most. Someone fills in a form, says exactly when they’d like to come in or what they’re after, and the reply says something like “the team will contact you to confirm”. Their booking isn’t confirmed. Nothing has happened. They’ve done their bit and now they’re waiting on you.
That’s the moment people drift. They meant it when they filled in the form, then life gets in the way, and by the time someone calls them back the moment has gone.
The fix is usually simple. If they can book there and then, let them. Put a booking button in the very first message. Better still, let them pick a slot on the page itself, so the confirmation can say “you’re booked in for Monday” rather than “we’ll be in touch”. If the time doesn’t suit, they can let you know. From their side, it’s done.
It also changes everything that comes after. Once someone has a slot, the follow-up stops being “are you still interested?” and becomes useful: what to bring, what to expect, how to change the time if they need to.
Front-load the value
The other common leak is follow-up that’s polite but empty. A sequence of gentle check-ins. Any questions? Still interested? We haven’t heard from you.
There’s nothing wrong with checking in. But if the first few messages don’t tell people what they’re actually going to get, there’s not much reason to reply. I’d rather front-load it. This is what you’ll get. This is how it works. This is what people tend to get out of it. Give them the reason to act early, while they’re still thinking about you, rather than saving it for the fifth email.
Timing matters as much as wording. A message that arrives while someone’s at work gets skimmed and forgotten. One that lands in the evening, when they’ve sat back down, is more likely to get a reply. And if you’re going to call or text, tell them which number it’ll come from and ask them to save it. A lot of people ignore a number they don’t recognise.
None of this is rocket science. It’s just the part that gets set up once and left alone.
Automation doesn’t replace the phone call
I build a lot of these follow-up flows, so I’ll be honest about what they’re for.
A phone call is always going to be better if you can get hold of someone. Automation doesn’t change that. What it does is make sure nobody is missed. If a busy week brings in far more enquiries than usual, every one of those people has been contacted, straight away, whether or not anyone has had time to pick up the phone. When you do get round to calling, you can see who has engaged and who hasn’t.
Two cautions from experience. First, don’t pour every raw enquiry straight into your main customer system. You end up with a growing database of people you know nothing about, some real, some not. Wait until they’ve done something real, like booking. Second, keep the data clean, because one day you’ll want to send all of those past enquiries a fresh reason to come back, and messaging a messy list costs money for every name on it.
Change one thing, then look
Once you’ve found the leak, it’s tempting to fix the page, rewrite the emails, switch the form and refresh the ads all in the same week. Then if things improve, you don’t know why. If they don’t, you don’t know what to undo.
So write down where you are today: how many people arrive, how many enquire, how many turn up or buy. Then change one thing and give it a proper run. If you’re not sure whether a page or a simple form converts better, run both side by side for a week and see where the customers actually come from. A landing page gives you more flexibility to improve things, but let the results tell you, not your gut.
It’s the same order I use for most work. Get clear on the problem, measure the before, change one thing, and only then move on to the next.
A quick check you can do this week
- Click your own ad and go through the whole journey as a customer, including two weeks of follow-up.
- Find the first point where you’d be left waiting, and see if you can let people book or act there instead.
- Read your follow-up messages in order. If the first two don’t tell people what they’ll get, rewrite them.
- Check when your messages actually go out, and move them to a time people can reply.
- Note your current numbers before you change anything, then change one thing.
If you’d like a second pair of eyes
This is a big part of what I do. I look at what happens between someone clicking and someone becoming a customer, find where people are dropping out, and then set up the follow-up and booking so it runs without anyone having to chase. Quite often it’s a simple change.
If enquiries are coming in but not turning into customers, I’m happy to talk it through. No obligation, just a conversation about what’s happening after the click.

